Book Review: Caraval by Stephanie Garber

They say Caraval is only a game. But when Scarlett enters the legendary spectacle she’s dreamed of her entire life, the magic, mystery, and danger quickly become all too real. In a world where every clue may be a trick and every ally may be an illusion, Scarlett must decide who—and what—she can truly trust.

---

Caraval

Stephanie Garber

Caraval, #1

Publisher: Flatiron Books

Published Date: January 31, 2017

Genres: Fantasy, Romance, Young Adult, Fiction

407 Pages / 10 Hours 6 Minutes

Date Read: February 25-March 1, 2026

Format: 📖

Source: Physical TBR

This is book one of a completed trilogy. As always, if you prefer a spoiler free review please read my quick review instead of the in depth review below.

---

About the Book

Scarlett’s father has arranged for her to be married. Scarlett and her sister, Tella, dream of seeing the once-a-year performance called Caraval. Thanks to their cruel father, Scarlett’s dream may be over. Tella has a plan that involves whisking Scarlett off to the show. Her plan did not involve her getting kidnapped by Caraval’s organizer. Now Scarlett and their mysterious sailer escort must work to find Tella.

Quick Review (Spoiler Free)

I really enjoyed this one. It kept my interest the whole way through. The characters were all intertwined so nicely. The story felt unique and well-paced. It was such a fun concept with a weirdly dark twist. I kept thinking I knew what was happening during the spiral of events. Definitely adding this to my favorite books list.

---

Now, let's get into the details!!

(Note: Some text may appear to be blocked out, just highlight that text to read it.)

I have been meaning to read this since I read Once Upon a Broken Heart. A friend recommended that I read this trilogy first since there are some easter egg type references in OUABH that go back to this.

I was not expecting to like this series just as much. I was thinking that Evangeline and Jacks couldn't be topped but I was not expecting Scarlett and Julian.

I already think carnivals are a little creepy so I absolutely loved the dark take on a carnival island that this story presented. I really want to know more about Legend and Dante and hope that the next book gives us more information on them. Tella and Scarlett are so fun together. They are literally yin and yang vibes. Scarlett and Julian's sarcastic banter was a fun highlight to their dark surroundings.

Also, can I say how creepy the Count is? What is up with him?! Do we get to know more?

... And her dad can kick rocks. That is all.

---

Ratings